The Language of Knitting

I’ve knit for a long time. I have old issues of Family Circle with knitting patterns, I remember when Red Heart was just about the only yarn out there for the average knitter. I remember when slp 1, k1, psso was the authoritative way to do a left-leaning decrease. There were no ssk, spk, or all the infinite variations one can find on the internet today.

Knitting these days is a whole new re-birth of the craft. There are wonderful free patterns on the internet, blogs that share FO’s and UFO’s, boards to share and commiserate, store sites to boggle the mind and pocketbook, and Ravelry to get us distracted from the actual knitting.

But at heart, knitting, if it involves a written pattern, still involves the knitter sitting with yarn, needles and a pattern to be interpreted. We cannot escape the need to speak the language of knitting. The thing is, which dialect are we speaking? Are we in “Knitty” land, or one of the older variations. How does this particular pattern envision the simple or not-so-simple yarnover?

So, I got this lovely Ladder Lace Shrug pattern by Ivy Mok as part of a purchase at CommuKnity on the Peninsula to Pier LYShop Hop last month. I took it with me on a short retreat to this beautiful place

and by the looks of the pattern (two rows long for the main lace pattern) I thought this would be a mindless knit. I needed a mindless knit. Then I read the pattern, and tried it, and all of a sudden my years of ignoring those pesky little details of yarnover variations became clear.

I’ve always been confused by the variations in how knitters describe putting the yarn over the needle to make a whole, except for the most simple yarnover between knit stitches. That one I’ve got down.These two rows bit my you-know-what. I literally put the whole thing down, because I was second-guessing myself – was this variation of a yarnover big enough? Is the hole the way the designer intended? How lacey should this lace pattern be?

(I’ll note that far more experienced lace knitters have run up against this language issue — Alison Hyde told me that she and her editor of “Wrapped in Comfort” do their yarnovers differently and had different notions of what she was intending. It makes me feel better to hear this.)

These are indeed the existential questions of knitting. Am I doing it “right” or right enough for me? What language is this pattern-maker writing?

Well, this is how my ladder lace shrug looks before sewing it together. I hope Ivy approves.

In another burst of lace knitting, I finished the Tuscany Shawl from No Sheep for You, this in Alfabeto from Artfibers. Those yarnovers are always between knit stitches, so my main problem was counting up to 10 over, and over, and over again.

I like it. Amy and I speak the same dialect of knitting!

6 replies on “The Language of Knitting”

Wrapping the yarnover the way I wrote makes for a larger hole and looser gauge than the way she illustrated. The funny thing is, there are two people in my knitting group I consider to be superb and experienced laceknitters: one, it did not occur to her that there was a different way to wrap the yarnover from how she does it, and the other, one of my test knitters, assured her, oh yes, and it really makes a difference on the size of the hole.

That it emphatically does.

Yep, I can see that the different ways of YO do make a difference. I finally did what I would consider a “double YO” to get the kind of lacey-rib for the shrug. Not sure that’s what the pattern writer had in mind, but it worked!

I bought that same pattern by Ivy Mok, Ladder Lace Shrug. I had planned to make two of them as Christmas gifts for my sisters.

I redid the pattern at least five times and for some reason it was not matching up at the end of the row. I took it in to the knit doctor at Green Planet yarn in Campbell, (Commuknity, unfortunately, was not open anymore, to ask for their help).

So, this project has been idle for at least four years! I spent a pretty penny on it. The Knit Dr. at Campbell said that their is a mathematical mistake somewhere along the way in the pattern. She spent some time on it and that was her finding.

Is there now a new revised version? I really would like to make them, but I have lost my steam. Now, seeing that you had made it, I wonder where I went wrong, was it the yarnovers….? I have about 5 inches worth still, maybe I should post a picture of it…

Please let me know if you had any complications and how you plowed through.
I really gave it a good shot and I am a decent knitter and I have had lace experience!
Please help me!! I have these beautiful hand dyed yarn for this project just getting dusty!

knit by knit I hope to figure it out.

Sorry, I knit this project ages ago, and gave it away, so any details about it are long gone from my memory. I probably fudged any stitch count issues, the result looked ok to me.

Maybe find another shrug pattern?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.